Skip to main content

FBR must inform taxpayers about basis of their income’s audit, LHC rules

LAHORE: The Lahore High Court has ruled that the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is bound to inform taxpayers about the parameters, if requested, on the basis of which they are selected for audit.

“The Board shall keep the parameters confidential. However, once persons or classes of persons are selected for audit under section 214C of Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, they shall be informed about the particular risk parameter applied to them for selection of audit, if demanded by them for their information,” says a judgement announced by Justice Abid Aziz Sheikh on a set of petitions challenging the power of the FBR to keep the parameters confidential for being contrary to fundamental rights.

Advocate Mohammad Ajmal Khan, one of the counsel for the petitioners, argued that the provision of subsection (1A) of section 214C of Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, which required the FBR to keep the parameters for selection of case for audit confidential was ultra vires of provision of Articles 4,8,10-A,19 and 19-A of the Constitution.

He said the decision of the board to keep the parameters for selection of audit confidential was also against the law settled by the high court.

Another counsel, Naveed A. Andrabi, argued that the impugned section did not specifically restrain the FBR after selection from disclosing the specific parameter on the basis of which the taxpayer persons or classes were selected for audit. He said the board had been misconstruing the provision.

Advocate Liaqat Ali Chaudhry on behalf of the FBR argued that mere selection for audit did not cause any actionable injury to tax payers. He said guidelines for selection of audit were administrative in nature and meant only for internal consumption of tax authorities, therefore, no fundamental right of the petitioners had been infringed for not disclosing the guidelines.

He said the restriction through the impugned provision on right of information, was reasonable to avoid tax evasion.

A deputy attorney general representing the federation adopted the arguments of the FBR and also questioned the maintainability of the petitions.

Justice Sheikh rejected an argument of the FBR counsel as baseless that parameters for audit selection was not a “matter of public importance” and Article 19-A of the constitution was not applicable in the matter.

The judge observed that the right to information under Articles 19 and 19-A of the constitution was well entrenched fundamental right of every citizen and the people had the right to know every public act and everything done in the public way by public functionaries.

Rejecting another argument of the board, the judge ruled that the courts had already declared in number of cases that disclosure of parameters was never considered a threat resulting in evasion of tax or frustration of Audit Policy. “Rather the courts have repeatedly held that risk parameters should be fair and publically advertised for the sake of taxpayer convenience,” added the judge.

Partially allowing the petitions, the judge declared that the impugned orders for not disclosing the specific parameters to petitioners for selection of their cases for audit were illegal and without lawful authority.

“The FBR is directed to inform the petitioners forthwith if requested by them, the specific parameters on the basis of which, their cases were selected for audit under section 214C of the Ordinance,” the judgement concluded.

Published in Dawn, June 28th, 2019



from The Dawn News - Home https://ift.tt/2YjdBVZ
via IFTTT
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Trump says he urged team to ‘slow’ COVID-19 testing

US President Donald Trump said Saturday he was encouraging health officials in his administration to slow down coronavirus testing, arguing that increased tests lead to more cases being discovered. The president has claimed falsely on several occasions that surges of COVID-19 in several states can be explained by greater numbers of diagnostic tests. At his first rally since the outbreak forced nationwide shutdowns in March, Trump told the crowd in Tulsa, Oklahoma that testing was a “double-edged sword.” The United States — which has more deaths and cases than any other country — has carried out more than 25 million coronavirus tests, placing it outside the top 20 countries in the world, per capita. “Here is the bad part: When you do testing to that extent, you are going to find more people, you will find more cases,” Trump argued. “So I said to my people ‘slow the testing down.’ They test and they test.” It was not clear from Trump’s tone if he was playing to the crowd, who ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sir Anwer Pervez, richest Pakistani British businessman, loses £432m in pandemic

Sir Anwar Pervez OBE, the founder and chairman of Bestway Cash & Carry has lost £432 million during the coronavirus pandemic to bring him down to No 50 on the richest British people list. The list has 1,000 people and is published by the Sunday Times newspaper . Pervez was at No 42 previously.  The 2020 list of the UK’s richest shows its first fall in wealth in a decade as Britain’s wealthiest people lost tens of billions of pounds in the coronavirus pandemic, the Sunday Times reported in its Rich List 2020. The newspaper, which has produced the respected annual ranking of the country’s 1,000 wealthiest people since 1989, found the past two months had resulted in the super-rich losing £54 billion ($65 billion). More than half of the billionaires in Britain had seen drops in their worth by as much as £6b, a decrease in their collective wealth unprecedented since 2009 and the financial crisis. The Hinduja brothers, who topped last year’s list with a £22b fortune, saw among ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Despite reservations about jury, Pakistan to implement FATF reforms: envoy

WASHINGTON: Despite its reservations about the fairness of the jury which is to determine Pakistan’s performance against terror financing, the government is committed to implementing its action plan for dealing with this issue, says Islamabad’s Washington envoy Asad Majeed Khan. In a conversation with a prominent US scholar George Perkovich, recorded at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in Washington on Monday afternoon, Ambassador Khan said the actions that Pakistan had taken so far to eliminate terror financing were “reflective of the political will”. “We feel that we have done a lot. We are also clear and determined to do more,” said the envoy while responding to a question about a meeting of the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) held in Orlando last week, which asked Pakistan to implement its own action plan for eliminating terror financing by October. Failing to do so could put Pakistan on a blacklist of violators and bring strict economic sanctions too. “But we w...
Post a Comment
Read more